You can lead a person to iNaturalist...

...but you can't make them upload.

Person on a listserv (paraphrased): I saw this interesting thing that I'd like help identifying. Can anyone look at it for me and explain the behavior?

Me: I recommend submitting it to and adding it to any regionally or taxonomically relevant projects to help it get noticed. Email me your user ID and I'll try to help tag some people who might be helpful.

Person: Thanks for your suggestion. Would you be able to put me in direct contact with anyone who could help with the ID? It would be great if I could talk directly with a specialist, since I have a number of questions about the behavior I observed.

Me: I have one idea of an iNat user who does a lot of macro invertebrate monitoring who might know more. Hopefully on iNaturalist you'll come across a specialist and can ask. After all, it's a social network for naturalists. :-)

Person: Hello--were you able to find anyone who might be able to help me identify this species from the photo I sent?

Me: Did you upload it to iNaturalist yet?

Person: I appreciate the suggestion, but I'd much rather contact an entomologist who works with the group--I was hoping you might be able to recommend someone.

Me: headdesk

I should have just sent him to BugGuide.

Anotado por carrieseltzer carrieseltzer, 06 de octubre de 2015 a las 06:21 PM


There are days when all the chocolate/wine/running/self-medication-of-choice just won't help.

Anotado por anneclewis hace mas de 6 años (Advertencia)


Yes, it can be a difficult process to get others to upload... What I have done in some cases is upload the image for the person with a 'community' username (I use the name olivernaturepark)... Then, if he or she realizes how that adds to the broad knowledge of the species distribution besides just "finding out what to call it," that might entice them to upload more later...

Ooooooor, you can just say "b-bye." ;)

Anotado por sambiology hace mas de 6 años (Advertencia)

Some are just interested in an id; others are interested in contributing to the knowledge base of iNat.

Anotado por lynnwatson hace mas de 6 años (Advertencia)

Uuuuuuh, that sounds all too familiar!

Anotado por jakob hace mas de 6 años (Advertencia)

Yeah Jakob it just happened for me with AfriBats on Facebook too :-/

Anotado por carrieseltzer hace mas de 6 años (Advertencia)

Very well written and utterly-frustratingly recognizable! Thank you for sharing this!

Anotado por rjadams55 hace mas de 6 años (Advertencia)

Beyond the paraphrased first request, it's verbatim!

Anotado por carrieseltzer hace mas de 6 años (Advertencia)

i usually end up ignoring those people since i am not mandated by my job to deal with them (unless I am)

Anotado por charlie hace cerca de 6 años (Advertencia)

Añade un comentario

Entra o Regístrate para añadir comentarios